Economic Policy Review Executive Summary
Are Home Prices the Next "Bubble"?
Recapping an article from the December 2004 issue
Contact authors
E-mail authors
of the Economic Policy Review, Volume 10, Number 3
View full article PDF


17 pages / 238 kb

Authors: Jonathan McCarthy and Richard W. Peach

Index of executive summaries
  • Home prices have been rising rapidly since the mid-1990s. Many analysts view the increase as symptomatic of a bubble that will burst, thus erasing a significant portion of household wealth. This decline in wealth could have a negative effect on the broader economy as consumers reduce spending to increase saving and protect their vulnerable financial condition.

  • Authors McCarthy and Peach argue that no bubble exists and present evidence that the marked rise in home prices is largely attributable to strong market fundamentals: Home prices have essentially moved in line with increases in family income and declines in nominal mortgage interest rates.

  • The authors begin their analysis by pointing out flaws in the two measures often cited to support the theory that a bubble exists—the rising price-to-income ratio and the declining rent-to-price ratio. Specifically, the measures
    • do not account for the effects of declining nominal mortgage interest rates and

    • fail to use appropriate home price indexes that control for location and changes in quality.
  • McCarthy and Peach contend that a weakening of economic conditions is unlikely to trigger a severe drop in home prices. In fact, aggregate real home prices historically have fallen only moderately in periods of recession and high nominal interest rates.

  • Nevertheless, weakening fundamentals could pressure prices along the east and west coasts, where an inelastic housing supply has made prices more volatile than elsewhere in the United States. However, previous home price declines in these regions have not had devastating effects on the national economy.

About the Authors

Jonathan McCarthy is a senior economist and Richard W. Peach a vice president at the Federal Reserve Bank of New York.


The views expressed in this summary are those of the authors and do not necessarily reflect the position of the Federal Reserve Bank of New York or the Federal Reserve System.

By continuing to use our site, you agree to our Terms of Use and Privacy Statement. You can learn more about how we use cookies by reviewing our Privacy Statement.   Close