Economic Policy Review Executive Summary
Below the Line: Estimates of Negative Equity among Nonprime Mortgage Borrowers
Recapping an article from the July 2009 issue
Contact author
E-mail authors
of the Economic Policy Review, Volume 15, Number 1 View full article PDF

13 pages / 383 kb

Authors: Andrew F. Haughwout and Ebiere Okah

Index of executive summaries
  • The 2004-06 boom in nonprime mortgage lending in the United States was quickly followed by a spike in the rate of delinquencies and defaults on these loans.

  • Evidence from the current downturn suggests that declines in house prices—or, more precisely, reductions in borrower equity—are key contributors to delinquencies and defaults.

  • To better understand and respond to the foreclosure crisis, policymakers are turning to measures of negative equity, in which the value of a property is below the property's mortgage balance.

  • Haughwout and Okah estimate negative equity in the U.S. nonprime mortgage market for 2008-09 to describe the sources of the problem and the characteristics of borrowers “below the line.” They combine information from house price indexes with data on individual loans to gauge the prevalence and magnitude of negative equity across various dimensions, including the location of the property and the year in which the mortgage originated.

  • The study finds that nonprime borrowers in negative equity share several characteristics: for example, they took out loans near the peak of the housing market and their mortgages had high loan-to-value ratios usually achieved with subordinate liens.

  • In addition, borrowers in negative equity are twice as likely as those in positive equity to be seriously delinquent, or in default, on their first-lien mortgage.

  • Haughwout and Okah also show that while negative equity loans exist in most U.S. metro areas, they are disproportionately concentrated in housing markets that experienced especially large swings in house price appreciation, particularly in California.

  • The authors’ results also suggest that if house prices fall an additional 10 percent from December 2008 levels, about 1.5 million new mortgages nationwide will be in negative equity; the aggregate difference between these balances and house values could reach $135 billion.

About the Authors

Andrew F. Haughwout is an assistant vice president and Ebiere Okah an assistant economist at the Federal Reserve Bank of New York.


The views expressed in this summary are those of the authors and do not necessarily reflect the position of the Federal Reserve Bank of New York or the Federal Reserve System.

By continuing to use our site, you agree to our Terms of Use and Privacy Statement. You can learn more about how we use cookies by reviewing our Privacy Statement.   Close